An employee says she will kill her supervisor. Another is caught smoking cannabis near a safety-sensitive manufacturing plant. A third has thousands of emails containing confidential client information copied onto a USB key she keeps at home.
Each case involved serious misconduct. Yet in none of these cases was dismissal for cause upheld.
These outcomes illustrate an important distinction in employment law: proving misconduct is not the same as proving just cause for dismissal. The question is not simply whether the employee did something wrong, or even something seriously wrong. It is whether the nature and circumstances of the misconduct justify ending the employment relationship without notice.
Under McKinley v. BC Tel, 2001 SCC 38, and Dowling v. Ontario (Workplace Safety and Insurance Board), 2004 CanLII 43692 (ON CA), the just cause analysis requires an assessment of the nature and extent of the misconduct, the surrounding circumstances, and the proportionality of dismissal. The ultimate question is whether the misconduct is reconcilable with the continued employment relationship.
Four decisions illustrate why employers must approach that assessment carefully. Two arise from labour arbitration, where arbitrators have authority to substitute a lesser penalty, and two from wrongful dismissal litigation. Although the legal and remedial contexts differ, the decisions offer important lessons about the evidence and analysis required to support dismissal for cause.
SerVantage: A Zero-Tolerance Policy Does Not Make Dismissal Automatic
In SerVantage Services Corp. v. Unifor Local 3000, 2026 CanLII 62024 (BC LA), a cleaner with 26 years of service admitted saying “I will kill him” about her supervisor following a disciplinary meeting. The employer dismissed her for cause, relying on the threat and her prior insubordination, and treated termination as automatic under its “zero tolerance policy.”
The arbitrator described the threat as “very, very serious misconduct” but found that dismissal was excessive.
The employer's own response was significant. The supervisor took no immediate safety precautions, building security was not alerted, and the employer contacted police only after receiving the grievance, approximately two weeks later. Management had also decided to terminate the grievor without first obtaining her explanation.
These circumstances undermined the employer's position that the threat made continued employment untenable. The arbitrator also considered the grievor's lengthy service, limited disciplinary record, candour and apology, and the spontaneous nature of the threat. A four-month unpaid suspension was substituted for discharge.
The lesson: A zero-tolerance policy does not eliminate the obligation to assess proportionality. Equally important, an employer's contemporaneous response to alleged misconduct may become critical evidence of how seriously it actually regarded the conduct and the risk it posed.
Continuous Colour Coat: Cannabis Use Is Not Proof of Impairment
In MSC Toronto o/a Continuous Colour Coat Ltd. v. USW Local 3950-65, 2026 CanLII 6010 (ON LA), a manager smelled cannabis as he passed an operator smoking near a safety-sensitive manufacturing plant. When suspended, the employee denied smoking cannabis and called a senior manager a “f****** joker.”
The arbitrator accepted that the employee had consumed cannabis and engaged in serious insubordination. There were also significant aggravating factors, including dishonesty, a failure to apologize and recent discipline.
Nevertheless, dismissal was found to be excessive.
Although the employer established cannabis use, it had no evidence of actual impairment. The manager who smelled the cannabis did not report the incident until the following day, by which time it was too late to assess impairment. The employer's policy also contemplated a range of disciplinary consequences, “up to and including termination,” rather than mandatory discharge.
The arbitrator substituted a three-month unpaid suspension.
The lesson: Employers must distinguish between evidence of cannabis use and evidence of impairment. Where impairment is material to the justification for dismissal, delays in investigating can compromise the employer's position. Policy wording also matters: a provision permitting termination does not necessarily make it the proportionate response.
Ratz-Cheung: A Serious Confidentiality Breach Does Not Necessarily Establish Cause
In Ratz-Cheung v. BMO Nesbitt Burns Inc., 2024 ONSC 161, an investment advisor with approximately 24 years of service had her husband copy more than 4,000 emails and attachments onto a USB key she kept at home. Some contained highly confidential client information, including social insurance numbers, dates of birth, asset deions and driver's licence information.
The employer discovered the conduct during examinations for discovery, after having dismissed the employee without cause, and amended its defence to allege after-acquired cause.
The Court found the copying and storing of the information outside the company problematic. However, the nature and extent of the misconduct were important. The employee had been entitled to access the emails. There was only one instance of copying, prompted by her belief that she was being treated unfairly at work, and she disclosed the emails to no one.
The Court characterized her conduct as a lapse in judgment for which a lesser sanction could have been imposed.
Importantly, the Court distinguished several decisions in which cause had been established, including:
- Steel v. Coast Capital Savings Credit Union, 2015 BCCA 127, involving deliberate, unauthorized access to a manager's personal file;
- Sonnilal v. Slimband, 2016 CarswellOnt 17102, involving the transfer of confidential patient information, together with other serious misconduct and unreliable testimony;
- Death v. Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, [2006] C.L.A.D. No. 342, involving repeated misuse of banking systems to access third parties' financial information; and
- Manak v. Workers' Compensation Board of British Columbia, 2018 BCSC 182, involving repeated disclosures of confidential employee information.
The distinction was not simply the volume or sensitivity of the information. The Court examined what the employee had been entitled to access, what she did with the information, whether it was disclosed, how often the conduct occurred, and the broader circumstances of the misconduct.
The lesson: A breach of confidentiality may be serious without necessarily making continued employment impossible. Employers should carefully examine the employee's access rights, intent, use of the information, disclosure, frequency and candour before asserting cause.
Williamson: A Disciplinary Record Cannot Substitute for Proof
The preceding decisions concern whether established misconduct justified dismissal. Williamson v. Brandt Tractor Inc., 2025 ONSC 2571, affirmed on the just cause issue in 2026 ONCA 272, addresses an equally important question: whether the employer proved the misconduct relied upon.
Brandt Tractor dismissed an 18-year employee with a lengthy disciplinary record following a customer complaint. The employer relied on the complaint as the culminating incident justifying termination.
The difficulty was evidentiary. The customer did not testify, and the employer failed to establish what had occurred during the encounter. The trial judge's adverse assessment of the employee's credibility could not fill that gap.
The Ontario Court of Appeal upheld the finding that just cause had not been established. Without admissible evidence proving the culminating incident, the employer could not rely on the employee's disciplinary history to justify dismissal.
The lesson: A history of misconduct may strengthen an employer's case where a further incident is established. It cannot substitute for proof of that incident. Employers must be prepared to prove the misconduct on which the termination decision rests, particularly where cause depends on a final or culminating event.
Before Asserting Just Cause: Four Questions Employers Should Ask
These decisions do not suggest that threats, drug use, dishonesty or confidentiality breaches should be tolerated. Nor do they mean that an employer must always impose progressive discipline before dismissing an employee for cause. Serious misconduct can justify immediate dismissal. What these decisions demonstrate, however, is that the seriousness of the allegation cannot replace the evidentiary and contextual analysis necessary to establish cause.
Before proceeding with a dismissal for cause, employers and their counsel should be able to answer four questions:
1. What exactly can we prove?
Identify the specific misconduct, the evidence supporting each allegation and any material gaps. Distinguish cannabis use from impairment, authorized access from unauthorized disclosure, and a reported complaint from a proven incident. Do not assume that an employee's dishonesty or lack of credibility proves every allegation against them.
2. Does our investigation support the conclusion we intend to advance?
Consider whether witnesses were interviewed, contemporaneous evidence preserved, the employee afforded an opportunity to respond, and relevant safety or operational concerns addressed promptly. Delays, inconsistent responses and gaps in the investigation may materially weaken the case for cause.
3. What do our policies actually require?
Review the applicable policies, the employee's knowledge of them, and how they have been enforced. A policy allowing discipline “up to and including termination” does not make discharge automatic. Even a zero-tolerance policy must be considered in the applicable legal and factual context.
4. Why is dismissal, rather than a lesser sanction, justified?
Assess the employee's position, length of service, disciplinary history, candour, remorse, the seriousness and consequences of the misconduct, and the extent to which trust has been compromised. Most importantly, identify why the misconduct is incompatible with continuing the employment relationship.
The practical distinction is significant. An employer may have ample grounds to discipline an employee but insufficient grounds to dismiss without notice. Before asserting just cause, the employer must be prepared to establish not only what the employee did, but why those actions justified bringing the employment relationship to an immediate end.
Any article or other information or content expressed or made available in this Section is that of the respective author(s) and not of the OBA.