Skip to main content

From Intake to Trial, Part 1: Opinion, Negotiation and Pleadings

November 16, 2026 | Sukriti Singh N.

Why I spent a Tuesday on the life cycle of a wrongful dismissal claim

Most employment files look simple from the outside, but every stage carries its own traps, strategic choices and a fast-moving body of case law. The OBA's full-day program, Litigating an Employment File, followed a file the way it actually unfolds, with presenters from both sides of the bar. This two-part series distils the day into a practical roadmap.

One theme ran through every session: the Court of Appeal's August 2026 decision in Baker v. Van Dolder's Home Team Inc. (heard with Li v. Wayfair Canada ULC), 2026 ONCA 568.

A. The initial opinion: get the contract analysis right first

Before you talk numbers, know which legal regime applies; everything later flows from this analysis.

Notice, enforceability and termination clauses

Is there a written employment agreement? If not, the employee is presumptively entitled to common law reasonable notice (Machtinger v. HOJ Industries Ltd., [1992] 1 SCR 986), assessed using the Bardal factors. If there is, three threshold questions follow:

  • Fixed term? Without an enforceable early termination clause, the balance of the term may be owed with no duty to mitigate (Kopyl v. Losani Homes (1998) Ltd., 2024 ONCA 199).

  • Signed midstream? New material terms need fresh consideration; continued employment is not enough (Holland v. Hostopia Inc., 2015 ONCA 762).

  • Has the job outgrown the contract? A substantial expansion of duties can make the original termination clause unenforceable (Celestini v. Shoplogix Inc., 2023 ONCA 131).

Then read every provision touching termination. Key ESA authorities include Wood v. Fred Deeley Imports Ltd., 2017 ONCA 158 (benefits during statutory notice), North v. Metaswitch Networks Corporation, 2017 ONCA 790 (base-salary-only calculations) and Waksdale v. Swegon North America Inc., 2020 ONCA 391 (an illegal "for cause" clause can sink a valid "without cause" clause).

Baker held that "at any time" or "for any reason" wording does not, on its own, breach the ESA, and reinforced a contextual reading of the agreement as a whole. The room read it as a partial swing back toward enforceability.

Employees are generally owed bonuses during notice unless the plan clearly removes that right (Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition Canada Ltd., 2020 SCC 26), and Wigdor v. Facebook Canada Ltd., 2026 ONCA 572 held that cutting off RSU vesting during statutory notice breaches the ESA. Watch too for "exceptional circumstances" pushing notice past the usual ceiling, such as very long service (Lynch v. Avaya Canada Corporation, 2023 ONCA 696; Panchbhaya v. Vulsay Industries Ltd., 2025 ONSC 5370) and niche positions (Warren v. Canaccord Genuity Corp., 2026 ONSC 547; Wigdor, 2025 ONSC 4861).

Restrictive covenants

Non-solicits must be reasonable in scope, duration and geography. For provincially regulated employees, non-competes entered into after October 25, 2021 are prohibited under the ESA, except on the sale of a business or for "executives" (s. 67.2(5)).

The "one-sided table" and day-one pitfalls

You usually hear one side of the story, so probe for flawed investigations, human rights issues or reprisal. Bad faith may mean the employer repudiated the contract and cannot rely on its termination clause (Potter v. New Brunswick Legal Aid Services Commission, 2015 SCC 10; Mohamed v. Information Systems Architects Inc., 2018 ONCA 428).

  • Mitigation. The standard is reasonableness, and the employer must now prove comparable employment was actually available (Williamson v. Brandt Tractor Inc., 2026 ONCA 272).

  • EI and records. Watch the Record of Employment, and tell the client to keep everything.

B. Pre-litigation: professionalism is strategy

Most files resolve before a claim is issued. The best advice: approach every file as though it is going to trial.

Negotiation and communication

  • Treat the demand letter as valuable real estate. Lead with clear calculations.

  • Anchor non-monetary terms early, such as reference letters and tax allocations.

  • Constructive dismissal is two different files. If the employee is leaving, prepare to litigate; if staying, focus on what the employer must fix.

  • Separate with prejudice and without prejudice content, and send litigation hold letters promptly.

The civility obligations in the LSO Rules of Professional Conduct (Rules 7.2-1, 7.2-1.1 and 7.2-5) apply in full.

Retainers and client management

For an organization, you act for the entity, not the HR contact (Rule 3.2-3). Contingency agreements must follow the Solicitors Act and O. Reg. 563/20 and define the scope carefully.

C. Pleadings: advocacy starts here

"Pleadings … frame the proceedings and the case that must be met" (PMC York Properties Inc. v. Siudak, 2022 ONCA 635).

Drafting effective pleadings

Under Rules 25.02 and 25.06, plead material facts, one allegation per paragraph. Structure is substance: single-allegation paragraphs allow a meaningful admission or denial.

  • Customize. Build the claim around the actual contract, termination and compensation picture.

  • Plead heads of damages distinctly (Rule 25.06(9)), each with its facts. An upsetting termination does not automatically justify moral or punitive damages.

  • Don't plead what you can't support (Abbasbayli v. Fiera Foods Company, 2021 ONCA 95), and particularize bad faith and malice (Patterson v. Eastern Residential Services Inc., 2026 ONCA 543).

  • Plead the contract as a whole after Baker: the full termination clause, related provisions and incorporated plans and policies.

My favourite line of the day: write without fear, edit without mercy.

Pleadings motions

Rule 21.01(1)(b) asks whether it is "plain and obvious" that no cause of action is disclosed (R. v. Imperial Tobacco Canada Ltd., 2011 SCC 42); Rule 25.11 strikes scandalous material; Rule 25.10 demands particulars. Target specific defects, move quickly, and expect leave to amend.

Coming in Part 2: discovery, mediation, motions and trial.

Any article or other information or content expressed or made available in this Section is that of the respective author(s) and not of the OBA.